Epigastric hernia management refers to the surgical repair of this type of hernia. Evidence-based surgical approaches describe the use of methods whose effectiveness has been scientifically proven when performing this repair. The foundation of this modern strategy is the use of mesh, particularly for hernias larger than 1 cm, as it provides tension-free repair and significantly reduces the risk of recurrence. Current treatment involves selecting the most appropriate method from open, laparoscopic (minimally invasive), or robotic techniques based on factors such as the patient’s individual condition, the characteristics of the hernia, and the surgeon’s expertise.
| What You Need to Know | Information |
| Definition of an Epigastric Hernia | An epigastric hernia is a type of hernia that occurs when fatty tissue or, in some cases, part of the intestine protrudes through a weak point in the abdominal wall between the navel and the lower border of the rib cage (epigastric region). |
| Anatomical Location of the Hernia | It develops along the linea alba, the connective tissue line in the midline of the upper abdomen above the navel. |
| Mechanism of Formation | Due to a small defect or weakness in the linea alba, increased intra-abdominal pressure pushes tissue through this opening. |
| Prevalence | It can occur in adults but is more commonly seen in young and middle-aged men. |
| Main Symptoms | A small, firm or soft swelling above the navel, becoming more noticeable with physical exertion, along with pain or discomfort in the epigastric region. |
| Characteristics of the Swelling | It is usually small in size and becomes more visible with coughing, straining, or heavy lifting. |
| Characteristics of the Pain | Pressure-like or pulling pain may occur in the upper abdomen and may increase after meals or during physical activity. |
| Causes | Increased intra-abdominal pressure, weak abdominal muscles, heavy lifting, obesity, chronic cough, constipation, and rapid weight gain or loss. |
| Risk Factors | Male sex, excess body weight, repetitive heavy physical exertion, and congenital weakness of the abdominal wall connective tissue. |
| Diagnostic Methods | A physical examination is usually sufficient for diagnosis; in suspicious cases, ultrasonography is used to evaluate the hernia. |
| Complications | Hernia incarceration, strangulation due to impaired blood circulation, and increased pain requiring emergency treatment may develop. |
| Treatment Approach | Definitive treatment is surgical, aiming to close the hernia defect and strengthen the abdominal wall. |
| Surgical Techniques | Repair may be performed using open or laparoscopic methods; in most cases, reinforcement with mesh is used. |
| Purpose of Surgery | To reduce symptoms, prevent enlargement of the hernia, and avoid serious complications such as incarceration. |
| Postoperative Process | Patients can usually return to normal activities within a short time, but heavy lifting should be avoided during the recovery period. |
| Prevention | Strengthening the abdominal muscles, maintaining an ideal body weight, avoiding heavy lifting, and treating conditions that increase abdominal pressure, such as constipation and chronic cough. |
What Is an Epigastric Hernia and Why Does It Develop?
You can think of the abdominal wall as a protective “corset” made of muscles and connective tissues that keep our internal organs in place. Along the exact midline of this corset is a very strong band of connective tissue called the “linea alba” (white line), which joins the right and left abdominal muscles. An epigastric hernia develops from a small congenital weak point or opening (defect) in this linea alba.
These hernias are called “primary” because they do not occur at the site of a previous surgical incision but rather arise from a weakness in the body’s natural anatomy. In most cases, the first structure to protrude through this opening is not an internal organ but the preperitoneal fat located just in front of the peritoneum. Over time, the defect may enlarge and, although rarely, may contain organs such as the stomach or small intestine.
Why does this weakness occur? There is usually a congenital predisposition. In some people, the connective tissue surrounding the tiny blood vessels that pass through the linea alba is structurally looser.
This congenital weakness usually becomes apparent when combined with conditions that increase “intra-abdominal pressure.” The increased pressure gradually enlarges the weak point and leads to the formation of the hernia. These factors include:
- Adiposity (Obesity)
- Chronic cough
- Chronic constipation (persistent straining)
- Professional heavy lifting
- Pregnancy
This demonstrates that successful repair is not simply about closing a hole but also about permanently reinforcing the underlying structural weakness of the tissue.
What Are the Symptoms and Risks of an Epigastric Hernia?
The clinical presentation of an epigastric hernia can vary greatly from person to person. Many patients may not even be aware of the hernia (asymptomatic), while others notice only a small, nut-sized swelling between the breastbone and the navel, particularly when standing.
In symptomatic patients, the following signs are commonly observed:
- Pain (especially during straining, coughing, or exercise, which may be dull or sharp)
- Swelling (located in the midline, palpable, and sometimes disappearing when lying down)
Although most epigastric hernias are small and harmless, they may rarely lead to serious complications requiring emergency surgery. The most significant risks are incarceration and strangulation.
Incarceration occurs when the contents of the hernia, usually fatty tissue or bowel, become trapped within the hernia sac and cannot be pushed back into the abdomen. This causes persistent pain and tenderness at the hernia site.
Strangulation is the next and far more dangerous stage. Blood flow to the trapped tissue, such as the intestine, becomes impaired. Once the blood supply is cut off, the tissue begins to die (gangrene), which may lead to bowel perforation and intra-abdominal infection (peritonitis).
Strangulation is a life-threatening emergency. Its symptoms include:
- Sudden, severe abdominal pain
- Nausea
- Vomiting
- An irreducible, extremely tender mass at the hernia site
- Fever
Because of these risks, surgical repair is recommended for symptomatic epigastric hernias or those that show signs of enlargement.
Is a Physical Examination Sufficient to Diagnose an Epigastric Hernia?
In lean patients, an epigastric hernia can usually be diagnosed easily through a simple clinical examination. The swelling becomes more prominent when the patient stands or strains. When the patient lies down, the surgeon can gently reduce the hernia and clearly feel the small fascial defect with a fingertip.
However, obesity completely changes this simple diagnostic picture. Obesity is not only one of the most important risk factors for developing an epigastric hernia but also significantly reduces the reliability of the physical examination. Thick subcutaneous fat may completely conceal small or medium-sized hernia defects.
Obesity changes the diagnostic equation because it:
- Is a major risk factor for hernia development.
- Significantly reduces the reliability of physical examination.
- May conceal the underlying hernia beneath thick subcutaneous fat.
- May even prevent incarcerated hernias from being detected during examination.
This creates a significant diagnostic dilemma, especially in patients who are candidates for bariatric surgery: in the population at the highest risk for hernias, the most basic diagnostic tool, physical examination, becomes the least reliable.
Therefore, in obese patients, especially during preoperative bariatric surgery evaluation, relying solely on clinical examination is insufficient if suspicious epigastric symptoms or a possible asymptomatic hernia are present. In this group, preoperative imaging is not optional but an essential part of surgical planning.
Which Imaging Methods (Ultrasound, CT) Are Used for an Epigastric Hernia?
Imaging methods play a critical role in confirming the diagnosis, determining the exact size of the hernia defect, identifying the contents of the hernia sac, whether fat, bowel, or stomach, and planning the surgical strategy.
Ultrasonography (US) offers many advantages:
- Reliable
- Radiation-free
- Widely available
- Cost-effective
- Allows dynamic examination during straining
The method known as Dynamic Abdominal Sonography for Hernia (DASH) is particularly valuable. During this examination, the patient is asked to strain while the ultrasound is performed. This provocative test makes it possible to detect small hernias that may not be visible when the patient is lying still and may even be more sensitive than static CT scans.
Computed Tomography (CT), however, is considered the gold standard for surgical planning. It provides a three-dimensional map of the hernia anatomy. Before surgery, the surgeon can clearly assess:
- A three-dimensional map of the hernia anatomy
- The exact dimensions of the defect
- The condition of the rectus muscles
- The relationship between the hernia contents and surrounding structures
CT is particularly necessary when a complicated hernia, such as strangulation, is suspected or when a complex anatomical repair such as eTEP or Rives-Stoppa is planned.
In summary, dynamic ultrasonography is generally the most sensitive tool for answering the question, “Is there a hernia?” especially when the physical examination is inconclusive. Computed tomography provides the clearest answer to the question, “What is the anatomy of the hernia, and how should it best be repaired?” particularly in obese patients or complex cases.
Why Is the “Suture-Only” Method Risky in Epigastric Hernia Repair?
The oldest and simplest method of epigastric hernia repair is primary suture repair (herniorrhaphy). In this technique, the surgeon simply stitches the edges of the hernia defect together without using mesh.
The main reason this technique fails is that it ignores the underlying cause of the epigastric hernia, namely the structural weakness of the linea alba.
The main problems with this method are:
- It ignores the underlying tissue weakness.
- It brings together weakened tissue under tension.
- Intra-abdominal pressure immediately places stress on the suture line after surgery.
- It results in high recurrence rates.
Scientific evidence on this subject is very clear. Numerous large studies have shown that primary suture repair has unacceptably high recurrence rates compared with mesh repair in defects larger than 1 cm.
Based on these findings, international hernia society guidelines have established a clear “1 cm rule”: primary suture repair should only be considered for carefully selected patients with defects smaller than 1 cm. Mesh repair is recommended as the gold standard for all defects larger than 1 cm.
Why Has Mesh Become the Gold Standard in Epigastric Hernia Repair?
The use of mesh in epigastric hernia repair has demonstrated overwhelming superiority over suture repair in reducing recurrence rates.
Mesh is a biologically compatible synthetic material. It reinforces the fascial defect without tension and compensates for the underlying tissue weakness. Over time, the body incorporates the mesh into its own tissue through fibrosis, creating a strong new layer of connective tissue. When the results of major studies are combined, mesh repair reduces the recurrence rate by approximately 70-80% compared with suture repair.
The most common concerns expressed by patients about mesh and the scientific facts are as follows:
- Concern: Infection (Fact: Modern meshes have not been shown to increase the risk of infection.)
- Concern: Hematoma / Blood Collection (Fact: Mesh has not been shown to increase this risk.)
- Concern: Seroma / Fluid Collection (Fact: There may be a slight increase in wound fluid accumulation, but this is generally manageable, as it is usually absorbed by the body over time or can be drained if necessary.)
- Concern: Chronic Pain (Fact: Contrary to the belief that “mesh causes pain,” chronic pain rates are similar after mesh and suture repair. In fact, hernia recurrence itself has been identified as the only independent risk factor for chronic pain.)
This last finding is particularly important: the method that most effectively prevents recurrence, namely mesh repair, is also the best long-term strategy for indirectly reducing the risk of chronic pain.
Where Should Mesh Be Placed in an Epigastric Hernia? (Onlay, Sublay, Rives-Stoppa)
Once the decision has been made to use mesh, the second most important factor determining surgical success is the anatomical layer in which the mesh is placed. The placement plane has a profound effect on repair strength and the risk of complications.
- Onlay (Subcutaneous) Placement (“Superficial” Method)
In this technique, the mesh is placed on top of the anterior rectus sheath, just beneath the subcutaneous fat.
Although technically simpler, it is biomechanically and physiologically the least favorable approach. Wide separation of the subcutaneous tissue from the muscle is required to place the mesh. Its disadvantages include:
- Creation of a large dead space.
- Poor blood supply.
- A high risk of seroma formation (more than 11% in some studies).
- A high risk of surgical site infection (approximately 2.3% in some studies).
For these reasons, this method is increasingly being abandoned in modern hernia surgery.
- Sublay / Retromuscular (Rives-Stoppa) Placement (“Deep and Anatomical” Method)
In this technique, the mesh is placed behind the rectus muscles (retromuscular) or in the preperitoneal space immediately in front of the peritoneum.
This approach is by far the most biomechanically superior. It can be compared to patching a punctured tire. If the patch is applied to the outside of the tire (Onlay), the internal air pressure pushes it away. However, if the patch is placed inside the tire (Sublay), the internal pressure presses it firmly against the wall, creating a stronger seal.
Its biomechanical advantages are undeniable:
- It turns intra-abdominal pressure into an advantage.
- The mesh is in contact with well-vascularized muscle tissue.
- The infection risk is very low (around 0.5%).
- The seroma risk is very low (around 0.7%).
- It provides proven low recurrence rates (approximately 3-4%).
For these reasons, this is the standard open surgical technique recommended by international guidelines.
What Is Laparoscopic Epigastric Hernia Repair? (IPOM Technique)
Minimally invasive surgery (MIS), commonly known as “keyhole surgery,” has become an important option for hernia repair, particularly because of its potential to reduce wound complications in obese patients.
The laparoscopic Intraperitoneal Onlay Mesh (IPOM) technique has long been the standard minimally invasive approach. Through several small incisions measuring approximately 0.5-1 cm, the surgeon inserts a camera and instruments into the abdominal cavity. The hernia sac is reduced, and a specially coated mesh, designed to prevent adhesion to the bowel, is fixed to the inner surface of the abdominal wall to cover the defect from inside.
This technique has both advantages and disadvantages:
- Advantage: Small incisions
- Advantage: Lower risk of wound infection
- Advantage: Faster recovery
- Disadvantage: The mesh comes into contact with the intestines, requiring a special coating.
- Disadvantage: There is a low risk of adhesions.
- Disadvantage: Metal or absorbable tacks used to secure the mesh may cause postoperative pain.
- Disadvantage: Long-term recurrence rates, reaching up to 15%, may be higher than with more modern techniques.
What Is the eTEP Technique for Epigastric Hernia and Why Has It Become So Popular?
The laparoscopic Enhanced-view Totally Extraperitoneal (eTEP) technique represents one of the most important advances in hernia surgery in recent years. It is considered revolutionary because it faithfully reproduces the proven principles of the Rives-Stoppa retromuscular repair using a minimally invasive approach.
In this technique, the surgeon works entirely between the layers of the abdominal wall without entering the abdominal cavity. Through small incisions, the ideal retromuscular space behind the rectus muscles is created endoscopically. The fascial defect is closed within this space, and the mesh is placed in this anatomically ideal extraperitoneal plane.
- eTEP combines the best features of both open and minimally invasive surgery.
- The mesh never comes into contact with the intestines or abdominal organs.
- There is no risk of adhesions.
- It is biomechanically as strong as the open Rives-Stoppa technique.
- Intra-abdominal pressure secures the mesh firmly against the abdominal wall.
- Painful fixation tacks are generally not required or are used only minimally.
- Postoperative pain is significantly less than with IPOM.
- Recovery is very rapid.
- It has proven extremely low infection rates, reported as 0% in some series.
- It offers low short- and mid-term recurrence rates of approximately 1-6%.
However, these advantages come at a cost. eTEP is technically much more demanding and requires a steep learning curve for the surgeon. Until sufficient experience is gained, the operation may take longer than IPOM.
What Is the Relationship Between Bariatric Surgery and Epigastric Hernia?
Obesity presents a dual challenge in epigastric hernia management, serving both as a major risk factor and as a surgical challenge. A high Body Mass Index (BMI) chronically increases intra-abdominal pressure, predisposing patients to hernia development.
From a surgical perspective, open hernia repair is technically more difficult in obese patients and carries a much higher risk of complications. Thick subcutaneous fat creates an ideal environment for wound infection and seroma formation.
When a hernia is detected in a patient scheduled for bariatric surgery, the surgeon considers three strategic timing options:
- Repairing the hernia before bariatric surgery.
- Repairing the hernia during bariatric surgery (simultaneously).
- Repairing the hernia after bariatric surgery, once the patient reaches an ideal weight.
Simultaneous repair is attractive because it spares the patient a second anesthesia. However, placing mesh during a bariatric procedure, such as sleeve gastrectomy, means implanting it in a clean-contaminated surgical field, theoretically increasing the risk of mesh infection. This decision should be individualized after weighing the risks and benefits.
Nevertheless, the evidence regarding the preferred approach in obese patients is clear. Compared with open repair, minimally invasive laparoscopic techniques offer:
- Significantly fewer wound infections (risk reduced by approximately 70-80%).
- Lower overall complication rates.
- Shorter hospital stays.
- Faster recovery.
In this patient population, open Onlay mesh repair should almost be considered a procedure to avoid because of its high complication rate. Preferred approaches include minimally invasive techniques such as eTEP or IPOM and, in selected cases, open retromuscular (Rives-Stoppa) repair.
Where Does Robotic Surgery Stand in the Treatment of Epigastric Hernia?
Robotic platforms, such as the da Vinci system, are increasingly used to facilitate technically demanding retromuscular dissections, particularly robotic eTEP (r-eTEP), while providing the surgeon with improved ergonomics, three-dimensional visualization, and enhanced precision.
The advantages and disadvantages of robotic surgery continue to be debated:
- Advantage: Better ergonomics for the surgeon.
- Advantage: May facilitate technically demanding procedures such as eTEP.
- Advantage: May reduce the risk of seroma formation.
- Advantage: May shorten hospital stay.
- Disadvantage: Very high cost.
- Disadvantage: Requires a long learning curve for the surgeon.
- Disadvantage/Warning: Very large retrospective studies involving more than 160,000 patients have reported higher 10-year recurrence rates (13.4%) following robotic repair compared with both laparoscopic and open approaches.
These findings demonstrate that technological advancement does not automatically translate into better surgical outcomes. The role of robotic surgery should therefore be evaluated carefully and critically against the proven results of open Rives-Stoppa and laparoscopic eTEP techniques.
What Are the Main Messages of International Guidelines for Epigastric Hernia Treatment?
The most current and comprehensive guidelines for the treatment of epigastric hernias are based on evidence-based medicine.
The main messages derived from the joint guidelines of the world’s leading hernia surgery societies are:
- Mesh should always be used in hernias larger than 1 cm to prevent recurrence.
- Suture repair is an option only for selected hernias smaller than 1 cm.
- In standard open surgery, the mesh should be placed in the biomechanically superior retromuscular (Rives-Stoppa) plane.
- Superficial Onlay mesh placement is not recommended because of its high complication rate.
- Minimally invasive laparoscopic techniques, particularly eTEP, should be considered for obese patients or those at high risk of wound complications.
- Adequate mesh overlap of at least 3-5 cm beyond the hernia defect in all directions is critical for preventing recurrence.
Frequently Asked Questions
An epigastric hernia most commonly presents as a lump, pain, tenderness, or a bulge between the navel and the breastbone that becomes more noticeable during coughing, heavy lifting, or straining. Some patients may have no symptoms.
An epigastric hernia develops because of weakening of the connective tissue in the front abdominal wall. Congenital predisposition, obesity, pregnancy, heavy lifting, chronic cough, and conditions that increase intra-abdominal pressure may increase the risk.
Small epigastric hernias may remain symptom-free for a long time. However, if the hernia contents become trapped or lose their blood supply, severe pain may develop and emergency surgery may be required.
No. An epigastric hernia does not close spontaneously. Although small, asymptomatic hernias may be monitored, permanent treatment is usually surgical repair. The treatment plan is based on the patient’s symptoms and the characteristics of the hernia.
In most patients, the diagnosis can be made by physical examination. When the examination is insufficient, ultrasound, computed tomography, or magnetic resonance imaging may be used.
Surgical treatment may be recommended for epigastric hernias that cause pain, gradually enlarge, interfere with daily life, or carry a risk of incarceration. The decision for surgery is made according to the patient’s overall condition and the characteristics of the hernia.
Recovery time varies depending on the surgical technique used and the patient’s overall health. Most patients can return to daily activities within a short period, although heavy lifting and strenuous exercise should be avoided for some time.
Although recurrence is uncommon after successful surgery, an epigastric hernia may rarely recur. Controlling risk factors such as excess weight, smoking, heavy lifting, and chronic cough may reduce the risk of recurrence.
Maintaining an ideal body weight, lifting heavy objects using proper technique, preventing constipation, treating chronic cough, and performing exercises that strengthen the abdominal muscles may help reduce the risk of developing an epigastric hernia.
If you notice a lump above the navel, pain, or suspect an epigastric hernia, you should consult a General Surgery specialist. Early evaluation is important for planning appropriate treatment and preventing possible complications.

Assoc. Prof. Dr. Aydincan Akdur is one of Türkiye’s leading academics and surgeons in the field of general surgery. He serves as the Head of the Department of General Surgery at Ankara Medipol University Faculty of Medicine and also sees patients in his private clinic in Çankaya. He is particularly known for his expertise in breast surgery, endocrine surgery, hepatopancreatobiliary surgery, colorectal surgery, and hernia surgery. Dr. Akdur graduated from Özel Yükseliş College in 1995 and completed his medical education at the Cumhuriyet University Faculty of Medicine in 2002. He completed his residency at the Başkent University Department of General Surgery in 2009. He received the academic title of Assistant Professor in 2014 and Associate Professor in 2021. Throughout his academic career, he has taken part in thousands of surgical operations and has successfully implemented modern surgical techniques particularly in breast and thyroid surgery, liver–pancreas surgery, colorectal surgery, and laparoscopic hernia procedures. Assoc. Prof. Dr. Akdur has 82 internationally indexed publications, over 400 citations, and more than 150 scientific presentations. His interest in minimally invasive surgery is combined with an approach that prioritizes patient safety and functional integrity. Today, Dr. Aydincan Akdur continues both his academic and clinical work at Ankara Medipol University and in his private clinic, standing out in the field of general surgery with his scientific expertise and ethical medical practice.
